ThredUp review

I mentioned a couple of months ago that I was planning on cleaning out my closet and trying out ThredUp, the online consignment store. ThredUp requires you to register and create a (free) account first. They have very clear info and policies online about how their consignments work, and I ordered a donation bag. I ordered a bag, called a “kit” on their site, in early August, and it took a couple of weeks for the “clean out bag” to arrive.

Librarian for Life + Style | ThredUp donation bag, empty

I then went through my closet — my husband and I took turns looking through our sides of the closet, and it really helped to have that extra, personal support to see us through the process — and as I took out items, I checked them against the brands checkup section on ThredUp. There are three categories for brands:  accepted, accepted with restrictions, and not accepted. I then put items that were on the accepted list into the donations bag.

Librarian for Life + Style | ThredUp donations

The items I sent to ThredUp included:

  • Grey long sweater with hoodie, as seen here
  • Denim jacket, as seen here (replaced with darker, more streamlined denim jacket here)
  • Dark grey chambray shirt, as seen here and here
  • Linen safari jacket with belt, as seen here and here
  • Black ponte knit dress, as seen here and here
  • Brown cropped cardigan, as seen here
  • Navy blue beribboned tee, as seen here

All of the items I donated were ones that I no longer wore or just didn’t fit right.

Librarian for Life + Style | ThredUp donation bag, full

I then sent off the bag for free through the USPS, and about a week or so later in early September, received an email from ThredUp stating that they had received my bag and had scheduled the review of my bag at a date two and a half weeks later. I then received another email from ThredUp a week later apologizing for the time delay and stating that they would be adding staff in order to be able to review donations bags more quickly in the future. I’m glad I received the follow-up email, because the timeline up to this point was feeling a bit over-extended. (Although, to be fair, their FAQs do state that processing currently takes between two and four weeks.) However, the date that I was assured (in another follow-up email) would be the date to check on my total — supposed to have been this past Monday, Sept. 28 — has come and gone, so I’m still waiting on the final verdict of what ThredUp decided to sell or not. Yep, my status is still stuck on “processing.” 😦

UPDATE:  Half an hour before this post was to go live, I checked my email and found another email update that my bag had finally been processed. I logged into my account, and saw that ThredUp did choose to sell almost everything I sent in. I now have a better idea now why things took longer than I expected. I didn’t realize that they also took photos and made records for each item before updating my account.

Info online indicates that they sell only 50-60% of what they receive in donations. You can pay a $12.99 fee for them to send back items they don’t choose to sell, but I decided not to do that. For items they don’t choose, ThredUp passes them on to third-party sellers or textile recycling partners to be repurposed. They also donate 10% of their recycled proceeds to Teach for America.

I appreciate how transparent ThredUp is about their policies and brands they accept and sell. I have to credit them for acknowledging the delays, but the extended timeline — it took two months from start to (almost?) finish — has been a definite drawback. Final verdict? If ThredUp does add staff to review donation bags more quickly, then I would probably use this method of donating clothes again. In the meantime, I will most likely stick to using local consignment stores.


6 thoughts on “ThredUp review

  1. Erin @ Loop Looks

    Thanks for sharing your experience! I’m impressed that they took everything you sent in. You really did your research.

    I think the last time I used them they also told me they were adding more staff to process things faster so have a feeling that’s just a standard email they always send out. Personally, for the amount of time, (lack of) money and restrictions that ThredUp offers, I prefer to take my stuff to a local consignment store. Even if that store is 10+ miles out of my way in a town I only go to once every few months.

    1. Jen @ Librarian for Life and Style Post author

      They took almost everything I sent in — and all but 1 item has already sold out online!

      And that is very interesting that you got the same email about adding more staff to process bags faster! Hmmm… and you’re right, there are a lot of restrictions. Things that weren’t on the “approved” lists I am saving up for a fall fashion swap this month! 🙂

  2. momofdox

    Thanks for sharing this review! A friend mentioned ThredUp to me as an alternative to selling my clothes/shoes on eBay. It seemed overly complicated to me. Your post helps explain things a little better, I think. Not sure I will use ThredUp; the wait time is a deterrent, and not knowing if any of my items will actually be accepted. There is a local consignment shop I can take things to, instead. If my stuff sells, great, and if not, she donates to the local women’s shelter. Win-win. I’ll stick with that and eBay.

    1. Jen @ Librarian for Life and Style Post author

      I totally support local consignment and thrift stores! I’m glad I tried out ThredUp, and I’ve heard good things about it from others. But it does take a long time, and there are quite a few hoops to jump through. I guess in the end, it’s good to have options to recycle and reuse clothing!

  3. CAPD

    I would agree as far as selling items there goes it’s not really a great deal. You could make more on ebay or local consignment shops, unless you want to just be able to throw stuff in a bag and not care how much it earn. It’s great for buying though!


Please leave a comment and share!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.